Microsoft Floor Laptop computer Studio 2 vs. Apple MacBook Professional: Which Is Greatest for Content material Execs?
Floor Laptop computer Studio 2 vs. MacBook Professional 14-Inch: Pricing and AvailabilityWhile loads of particular options differentiate the Floor Laptop computer Studio 2 and the MacBook Professional, they’re completely matched in a single space: Each techniques share a base worth of roughly $2,000 (should you skip the stripped-down vanilla-M3 MacBook Professional for a unit with the fascinating M3 Professional processor). Whereas that is an upward bump for Microsoft (the first-gen Laptop computer Studio remains to be on sale beginning at $1,599.99), the actual query is how upgraded configurations are priced, since many inventive execs will find yourself paying extra for the facility and efficiency they want.Probably the most primary Laptop computer Studio 2 with discrete graphics (an Nvidia GeForce RTX 4050 laptop computer GPU as a substitute of Intel’s Iris Xe built-in graphics) prices $2,399.99. Boosting the solid-state storage to 1TB and bumping the GPU to an RTX 4060 prices $3,299.99. Prime configurations go even greater (as much as $3,699).
(Credit score: Brian Westover)
As talked about, a base mannequin of the 14-inch MacBook Professional is $1,599, however for one thing providing the identical kind of processing and graphics muscle because the Studio 2, you will need the $1,999 M3 Professional configuration, which groups an 11-core processor (with 14 GPU cores) with 18GB of reminiscence and a 512GB solid-state drive.Stepping as much as a 12-core M3 Professional chip model with an 18-core GPU and 1TB of storage prices $2,399. An much more highly effective M3 Max model with 14 CPU and 30 GPU cores is $3,199. And if cash is not any object, you possibly can configure the 14-inch MacBook Professional to a loaded M3 Max platform with 16 CPU cores and 40 GPU cores, 128GB of RAM, and a colossal 8TB SSD for the super-premium worth of $6,899.For this comparability, we’re sticking with the $1,999 model of the 14-inch MacBook Professional with M3 Professional. Its 11-core CPU and 14-core GPU roughly match the Floor Laptop computer Studio 2’s Intel Core i7 and Nvidia GeForce RTX 4060.The Floor has extra storage (1TB versus 512GB), which is helpful however does not start to justify the value distinction. At $3,299.99, the Microsoft laptop computer is a whopping $1,300 greater than our Apple take a look at unit.Winner: MacBook ProSurface Laptop computer Studio 2 vs. MacBook Professional 14-Inch: ComponentsMicrosoft’s inventive laptop computer is available in two flavors: one for customers and the opposite for business clients. The first distinction is the processor, with the previous mannequin getting a thirteenth Gen Intel Core i7-13700H and the business model a Core i7-13800H. The 2 CPUs supply near-identical {hardware} and efficiency, although the Core i7-13800H has a barely greater Turbo Enhance max clock pace of 5.2GHz. Both chip could be paired with 16GB, 32GB, or 64GB of reminiscence.
(Credit score: Joseph Maldonado)
Graphics choices are extra diverse. The bottom mannequin, as talked about, depends on Iris Xe built-in graphics, that are superb for workplace productiveness however not suited to multimedia content material creation. Switching to a discrete GPU opens up extra choices, with each Nvidia’s GeForce RTX 4050 and 4060 out there in addition to a workstation-class Nvidia RTX 2000 Ada chip. (Microsoft hasn’t clarified whether or not the skilled GPU will probably be restricted to the business model of the laptop computer, however we would not be stunned.)Apple’s transfer to house-brand silicon in all of its MacBooks implies that each configuration has a variation on the M2 processor, whether or not M2 Professional or M2 Max, with totally different numbers of CPU and GPU cores out there. In our testing, these small variations have amounted to a giant deal, elevating the M2 Professional to the equal of a prime Intel CPU with discrete graphics whereas the M2 Max gives workstation-grade processing and graphics energy.
(Credit score: Joseph Maldonado)
Fortunately, we do not have to match Apple {hardware} to Intel oranges solely on specs and producer claims, as a result of we have benchmarked and reviewed each machines. The MacBook Professional leads the best way in duties like video transcoding. The Floor Laptop computer Studio 2 does extraordinarily properly, however the M3 Professional seems to have the higher hand, particularly in accelerated media workloads.All of this despite the truth that our 14-inch MacBook Professional is not even the height configuration—you possibly can scale it up with an M3 Max processor with even mightier graphics energy. The Apple positively wins this one.Winner: MacBook ProSurface Laptop computer Studio 2 vs. MacBook Professional 14-Inch: Connectivity and PortsConnectivity is extra vital than ever nowadays, however that simply means there’s an crucial for producers to supply one of the best networking {hardware} and port choice they will. For wi-fi work, each Microsoft and Apple have outfitted their inventive laptops with Wi-Fi 6E and Bluetooth 5.3.The port choice is a distinct story, nevertheless. Whereas each laptops are outfitted with two USB-C Thunderbolt 4 ports, their different I/O choices differ. The Floor Laptop computer Studio 2, for instance, features a microSD flash card reader. These card slots are uncommon on most client laptops however are nonetheless vital options for anybody capturing their very own images or movies for post-processing.
(Credit score: Joseph Maldonado)
Apple’s MacBook Professional additionally features a card slot, however it’s a full-size SDXC slot. Which is extra vital on your workflow will come right down to your alternative of kit: You need to use a microSD card in a full-size slot with a easy card adapter, however there is not any method to match a bigger card right into a smaller slot; you’d have to make use of an exterior USB adapter.
(Credit score: Brian Westover)
The MacBook Professional has one other characteristic many customers strongly really feel about: an HDMI output. That is an particularly vital connection for anybody working with video who needs to share their work on an even bigger exterior monitor or preview how a clip will look on a regular TV fairly than knowledgeable color-corrected show. Positive, you need to use a DisplayPort adapter dongle (or a Thunderbolt 4 dock with HDMI output) to do the identical on the Floor Laptop computer Studio 2, however the further {hardware} is extra problem than most folk wish to take care of.These are tiny particulars, however they’ve an outsize impact once they affect your work. On this case, we predict Apple has the sting as a result of addition of an HDMI port and its barely extra versatile card reader.Winner: MacBook ProSurface Laptop computer Studio 2 vs. MacBook Professional 14-Inch: DisplayAt first look, the 14.4-inch Floor Laptop computer Studio 2 show and 14.2-inch MacBook Professional display look extraordinarily comparable. What Microsoft calls a PixelSense Circulation display gives HDR assist, excessive decision, and nice brightness, whereas Apple’s Liquid Retina XDR panel does the identical.
(Credit score: Joseph Maldonado)
On paper, the 2 are intently matched. The Floor Laptop computer Studio 2 show is a fifth of an inch larger measured diagonally, and the panels have comparable densities of 200 pixels per inch (ppi) and 254ppi, respectively. The Apple can get slightly brighter when displaying HDR content material, however each are rated at 500 nits of brightness for regular SDR use.
(Credit score: Brian Westover)
However there’s extra to a display than simply visuals. A minimum of, there’s much more to the Floor Laptop computer Studio 2’s show, which provides each contact and pen assist together with a multi-position convertible design. That practical shift to interactive contact and multi-mode functionality makes Microsoft’s the extra compelling alternative by far. If it’s worthwhile to draw, annotate or mark up photographs, or simply get arms on with a undertaking, the Floor Laptop computer Studio 2 can serve you in methods the MacBook Professional cannot.In our instrumented testing, the Apple delivered barely higher colour high quality and superior HDR functionality, although the shows’ total high quality is remarkably shut. The Floor Laptop computer Studio 2 stands out for contact and pen assist and its convertible design, whereas the MacBook Professional narrowly wins in brightness and colour accuracy for customers prioritizing show high quality above all. The cut up between contact and pen assist and colour protection means we’re calling it a tie.Winner: TieSurface Laptop computer Studio 2 vs. MacBook Professional 14-Inch: CameraWhen the 14-inch MacBook Professional debuted, Microsoft’s and different Home windows laptops had been nonetheless settling for lowly 720p decision webcams, however that is modified. Full HD (1080p) decision is the present normal, and the Floor Laptop computer Studio 2 steps up additional by matching a number of the fancier options of Apple’s cameras.
(Credit score: Joseph Maldonado)
The Floor webcam provides options like automated framing, background blur, and even an AI-driven eye-contact mode. Apple has a few of these options, too, however just isn’t the clear winner it as soon as was. For this comparability, we’ll name it a photograph end.Winner: TieSurface Laptop computer Studio 2 vs. MacBook Professional 14-Inch: Battery LifeBoth Microsoft and Apple made huge claims about these laptops’ battery life once they had been introduced, however now that we have examined each, we are able to put laborious numbers to those guarantees of energy effectivity.Microsoft promised as much as 19 hours of typical utilization for the base-model Floor Laptop computer Studio 2, whereas Apple quoted 18 hours for streaming Apple TV and 12 hours when shopping the net over Wi-Fi. Since laptop computer distributors use totally different testing requirements, we apply the identical battery benchmark to all merchandise.
(Credit score: Brian Westover)
In our case, which means prolonged playback of a 720p video file, with matching settings for display brightness and audio quantity, Wi-Fi and keyboard backlighting turned off, and disabling any superior energy administration options which may skew the outcomes by altering our take a look at parameters. We noticed spectacular unplugged stamina from each techniques, however our instances had been nowhere close to the estimates from Microsoft and Apple. The Floor Laptop computer Studio 2 lasted a reasonably lengthy 15 hours and 23 minutes in our video rundown. For a desktop substitute with a discrete GPU, that is truly fairly good. However the 14-inch Apple MacBook Professional smashed class data with almost double the runtime—30 hours and 27 minutes, hours greater than Cupertino’s most optimistic declare.Any machine that may get by way of a full day of labor or faculty with out an AC outlet deserves reward, however that is no contest: The 14-inch MacBook Professional is the clear champ.Winner: MacBook ProSurface Laptop computer Studio 2 vs. MacBook Professional 14-Inch: SoftwareThe debate over whether or not Home windows or macOS is the superior working system is a long time previous, and we’re not about to settle it right here. However it’s in all probability the important thing think about deciding which inventive laptop computer is best for you.The Microsoft ecosystem provides {many professional} apps for photograph enhancing, graphic design, video work, and 3D and CGI rendering and engineering. Alongside the newest Floor laptops, Microsoft additionally launched a slew of AI-driven options coming to virtually each side of the Home windows expertise. Comparable options are being added to Adobe merchandise corresponding to Photoshop. The Floor Laptop computer Studio 2’s Core i7 processor does not embrace the built-in neural processing unit (NPU) present in Intel’s newer Core Extremely chips, however has a separate Intel AI chip on the mainboard dubbed Movidius.
(Credit score: Joseph Maldonado)
Apple’s M3 Professional and M3 Max processors additionally assist AI and machine studying, however macOS does not but supply the kind of deep integration of AI into frequent purposes that Redmond is promising for Home windows, the Microsoft 365 suite, and third-party apps. This will likely properly change with future variations of macOS, however at this writing, Apple is not aboard the AI bandwagon as Microsoft is. As with most Mac-versus-PC questions, it is in all probability principally about which platform you already use.Winner: TieVerdict: MacBook Professional Wins, However Floor Has Distinctive AppealAdd all of it up, and the M3 Professional model of Apple’s 14-inch MacBook Professional is the winner on most counts. With its stellar efficiency and bonkers battery life, it is as a lot a cellular workstation as it’s a mainstream laptop computer, and an simple asset for inventive professionals. The truth that you will get a extra highly effective system for lower than you’d spend on a Floor Laptop computer Studio 2 can be a reasonably decisive issue.However do not rely out the Microsoft machine fully. Its mixture of high-performance {hardware}, contact and pen assist, and pull-forward convertible design provides some issues no different laptop computer can, making it particularly engaging to artists who need full-featured drawing and inking with out having to pack alongside a pill or digital drawing pad.In the event you’re inquisitive about both of those techniques, take a look at our full evaluations of each the Apple MacBook Professional 14-inch (2023, M3 Professional) and the Microsoft Floor Laptop computer Studio 2.
