Concealers are one of many hardest merchandise to seek out that verify all of the bins, particularly with out breaking the financial institution. In a little bit of a role-reversal from an influencer standpoint, I polled my communities on Instagram and YouTube to find what they thought was the perfect drugstore beneath eye concealer in 2025. 4 concealers stood out as the preferred, and I put them to the take a look at to rank them primarily based on protection, texture, end and put on time.
Watch the video on the prime of the web page to see side-by-side comparisons and the way they appear after 9 hours of damage! Or, maintain scrolling for my fast ideas on every of those extremely rated drugstore concealers.
#4: L’Oreal True Match Serum Concealer
Purchase at Goal, Amazon
I’m an enormous fan of the L’Oreal True Match Basis, so certainly I’d love this concealer! This can be a make-up/skincare hybrid with 1.5% hyaluronic acid and caffeine within the method for hydration and de-puffing. I really like the pointed, iron-shaped applicator that match completely into the corners of my beneath eye.
The primary shock got here with the shade. L’Oreal advises shopping for the identical shade within the concealer because the corresponding basis that matches you. The muse in N3 is without doubt one of the finest shade matches I’ve ever discovered, however for some cause the concealer in the identical shade was tremendous mild. It’s undoubtedly not a 1:1 match and I believed it seemed slightly too cool for me.
With that mentioned, the skinny method presents a ton of protection and blends to an extremely easy, pure end. I believe the ultimate look is just like the smoothness setting powder offers, with out the additional step.
L’Oreal True Match Radiant Serum Concealer in N3
Whereas I preferred the general end, and it lasted properly over 9 hours, the dealbreaker got here within the glitter. Sure, glitter. There’s a bizarre pink/gold glitter on this method that I believe appears actually goofy. It appears unintentional– prefer it’s not a part of the concealer however simply sitting on prime of it. I’m not against shimmer in beneath eye concealers, however this simply wasn’t doing something for the precise end. It didn’t add glow, it simply added sparkle.
Actually, with out the glitter (and in a greater shade) this is able to have ranked a lot greater for me. Plus, it’s out there in 24 shades with a superb vary from honest to deep.
#3: Covergirl Merely Ageless Triple Motion Concealer
Purchase at Goal, Amazon
The Covergirl Merely Ageless Triple Motion concealer options Hyaluronic Advanced, Vitamin C & Niacinamide for an additional hybrid that provides TLC to the beneath eyes. What makes this concealer completely different than the rising skin-friendly concealers on cabinets, although, is the ceramic wand.
As you possibly can see, the applicator isn’t comfortable. It’s easy ceramic, which is meant to supply cooling, de-puffing advantages whereas gliding simply beneath the eyes. Frankly, this was very gimmicky to me. To start with, in the event you’re simply dotting on concealer, perhaps even swiping it, you’re not likely holding it beneath the eyes lengthy sufficient for the cooling sensation– which it does have!– to de-puff considerably. Moreover, it doesn’t pull out a ton of concealer with it, and so the dry components do find yourself tugging on the pores and skin.
Covergirl Merely Ageless Triple Motion Concealer in Basic Ivory
Regardless of my gripe with the applicator, the precise method is nice. As you possibly can see, it gave me good quantity of protection on a very darkish dark-circle day. It stayed trying easy and didn’t fade after 9 hours, both. Plus, with the method being non-comedogenic, it’s nonetheless a fantastic selection for delicate pores and skin if you will get previous the ceramic wand enterprise, and if you could find a shade match. That is solely out there in 12 shades, and the vary undoubtedly leans lighter.
#2: NYX Professional Repair Stick Correcting Concealer
Purchase at Ulta Magnificence, Amazon
For those who’re searching for a stable, handy, natural-looking and lengthy lasting concealer, the NYX Professional Repair Stick Concealer is a secure guess. The creamy texture is a bit thicker than the opposite concealers on this submit, nevertheless it blends out tremendous simply to a pure end with medium protection that… simply appears like pores and skin. It’s out there in 6 coloration correcting shades and 18 complexion shades, so you possibly can select the way it matches into your routine.
NYX Professional Repair Stick in Pure
Whereas this one isn’t a “skincare hybrid” just like the others featured right here, it does nonetheless include hyaluronic acid in order that it doesn’t really feel dry on the pores and skin. It’s tremendous comfy, with minimal fading all through the day.
#1: NYX Naked With Me Concealer Serum
Purchase at Ulta Magnificence, Amazon
Day after day of testing these concealers, the NYX Naked With Me Concealer Serum constantly impressed me. Once more, that is meant to supply skincare advantages with components like tremella mushroom, cica extract and inexperienced tea which assist hydrate and supply a pure glow with medium protection that helps conceal darkish circles, blemishes and dry pores and skin patches.
NYX Naked With Me Concealer Serum in Beige
The Naked With Me Concealer offers a radiant end that helps brighten the beneath eyes and easy out hole pockets. It’s simply the correct quantity of glow with out crossing into dewy territory. It blends in seamlessly, sufficient in order that you may apply simply this with out every other make-up on, and it wouldn’t be apparent.
Whereas I did expertise creasing with all concealers attributable to my private eye form (the deep crease beneath my eyes), the NYX Naked With Me Concealer Serum creased considerably much less. It seemed recent all day and maintained its protection for over 9 hours.
You additionally get a lot product on this tube. With that mentioned, the pump can take some getting used to. It’s not as exact as dotting on product with a wand, and may lend itself to losing concealer in the event you take out an excessive amount of. The slightest stress on the pump can provide me greater than sufficient for each eyes. To me, it’s a studying curve I’m prepared to deal with as a result of I respect slightly going a good distance.
General, I can see myself utilizing the NYX Naked With Me Concealer for many makes use of. I believe it really works rather well with my drier beneath eyes and features. Nevertheless, the NYX Professional Repair Stick could be very handy to make use of, offers nice protection and smoothing. It might in all probability make the minimize over the serum concealer for my journey make-up bag.
What do you suppose is the perfect drugstore beneath eye concealer?
– Miranda
